Two Taleo Users with the same User Types and User Group, only one can see Center Stage, Why?

Summary:

I have a new hire who was set up as a user in Taleo to mirror the profile and authorizations of a soon-to-be retiree. The outgoing employee sees Center Stage when she enters Recruiting from the landing pad. The new employee only sees the Welcome message.

Content (required):

I have a new hire who was set up as a user in Taleo to mirror the profile and authorizations of a soon-to-be retiree. The outgoing employee sees Center Stage when she enters Recruiting from the landing pad. The new employee only sees the Welcome message.

Additionally, I have set up a test user to replicate the new user and tried to make changes in Preferences to see if I could get it to display.