I recently realized that our 3-tier descriptive URL system (as /tab/category/item) is hurting us in google because each product has multiple pages if it's included in multiple categories. This means that are competing for rankings AND I'm being penalized for duplicate content.
I decided that changing to the single descriptive URLs (as /category or /item) would solve this problems... each item will only have one URL (/item_name) so there will be no duplicate content and all the traffic will be going to one page, so there won't be duplicate content duking it out for rankings, right?
Wrong... I've realized that when I switch to the short URLs, Netsuite is going to put query strings on the end of them in order to show which of the multiple categories the user clicked through.
This going to pose the exact same problem in a different form.
Isn't the googlebot going to index each drilldown separately by category AGAIN because of the different query strings associated with different categories? So my item pages can never achieve good rankings because there seems to be no way to get all traffic for a single item to go to a single item drilldown.
I forwarded a couple item URLs and the user gets forwarded to another category (maybe the first category listed for the item?) if the query strings are not included. This will confuse the hell out of shoppers and is NOT a solution.
The only solution I see is to put each item into only one category, which will successfully render Netsuite the worst CMS ever.
Why can't netsuite store these category query strings somewhere else, such as in SESSION variables... As it stands now, each item that is in more than one category generates duplicate content, which is getting my site penalized in the search engines... what are my options, put each item into only one category or shoot myself in the foot? Not to mention the fact that my page for "Product 1" will never realize it's potential in the search engines, because traffic is being routed to multiple places... /shop/category_1/product_1 & /shop/category_2/product_1... these 2 pages are competing for rankings instead of combining their "SEO juice" into one URL.
The only ray of light that I see here is that google might ignore the query stings and index them as one page if it sees that the content is nearly identical... I don't think this is the case, but I'd sure like for somebody to convince me that it is.
Thanks,
Jacob