We just implemented the Descriptive URLs for our web store http://www.parentmagicstore.com/parentmagicstore
The process was pretty seemless which was great!
Our SEO consultant, however, had the following concerns/questions. Can anyone address them? Thanks in advance for your help
1. I assume the system takes the product name and sticks it in the last portion of the URL. This is a good thing, but it sometimes creates URLs that “look like” you’re trying to spam the engines, as in:
http://www.parentmagicstore.com/All-Products/Parents-of-Kids-2-12/1-2-3-Magic-and-More-1-2-3-Magic-DVD-Package
All the hyphens in the file names may (just may) trigger some sort of anti-spam flags with the engines, who are always on the lookout for domains like www.buy-cheap-ring-tones-and-pills-online.com/cheap-ring-tones-for-your-cell-phone.html - you get the idea. The usual recommendation is to try to avoid more than 2 hyphens in a filename, and if the name is longer, just get rid of the hyphens and jam the words together without spaces. Another way to do it is to assign a unique name to each product that does not involve the entire text of the product name. I honestly don’t know if this would be an issue down the road, but it did raise a flag.
2. Plucking the product name into the URLs has another side-effect to be aware of. Every time you make the slightest change to the product name, the URL for that product changes (I assume that how the system works, if it doesn’t, I stand corrected). As a result, all links to the previous URL would break, all rankings lost, etc. It would appear to the engines to be a brand new content page because of the new URL. This is something to keep in mind.