We've used real-time rates with some items having a specified box. That has been our setup for years. It has the shortcoming of never knowing when we can slip a small item in with a large item that has a big box. Eg: Item A has a box in NetSuite and item B doesn't have any box. We can ship item B in the giant box that item A ships in, but we don't want to assign the giant box to item B or it would make it too expensive to ship by itself. As a result, a customer adding item B (the size of a cell-phone) to an order for item A makes the shipping jump way up even though in reality we slip it into the item A box and shipping goes up $0.00.
Then, we tried converting a bunch of items to free shipping. That failed. We did it with the advanced promotions method. It didn't accommodate for multiple coupon codes. It also didn't work with kit items and we have a lot of them
Just recently I switched to shipping by weight and we use $9 handling + $.70 per lb. I thought this might have an advantage of giving the furthest locations a shipping break at the expense of the closest locations. So, we pick up more of those long distance customers.
The main issue I have with the most recent settings is that they don't have a table for shipping by the pound.
Like
1 lb - 10 lbs ... $.8 per lb
11 lbs - 40 lbs ... $.7 per lb
40 lbs - 100 lbs ... $.6 per lb
As a result, it seems to over charge the heavier the order gets.
Any input on what other ecom companies are doing would be helpfull.