How do I set up an approval rule different for a certain department?

Summary:

Our Sheriff's Office wanted to have extra people notified when a new hire starts. I thought I set up the rule correctly so if it was for their department it would go through a different approval process. However, it looks like it is going through both rules. What am I missing?

Content (required):

Here are the rules I set up.

Here is what is happening:

Version (include the version you are using, if applicable):

23A

Code Snippet (add any code snippets that support your topic, if applicable):