Learning Plan Completions Not Updating

Summary

New course completion dates for courses in a Learning Plan are not updating.

Content

I have several learning plans that have to retaken by re-hires. When the re-hires recomplete the courses in the learning plan the completed on date would update with the most recent completion date. Now that date is not updating. It is keeping the first completed date. Was this an "enhancement" that I missed? 

NOTE: Yes I have multiple attempts and retain all completions turned on.