Oracle Analytics Forum

Home› Oracle Analytics and AI› Oracle Analytics and AI Forums› Oracle Analytics Forums› Oracle Analytics Forum

Categories

Welcome to the Oracle Analytics Community: Please complete your User Profile and upload your Profile Picture

Incorrect Difference from Two Calculations

Accepted answer
51
Views
5
Comments
Mirithu
Mirithu Rank 3 - Community Apprentice
edited Jan 22, 2025 7:13AM in Oracle Analytics Forum

Hello,
I am using Oracle Analytics Desktop and attempting to get the difference of two calculations as follows:

Calculation 1: COUNT(CD_CUSTOMER) = 1,064,910
Calculation 2: COUNT(CUSTOMERNUMBER) = 526,568

To get the difference of these two, I am dragging and dropping them into a new Edit Calculation window which pastes as:
(COUNT(CD_CUSTOMER)) - (COUNT(CUSTOMERNUMBER)). But the result is 581,037 instead of 538,342.

Why is the result coming out wrong? (There are no NULL values in both tables in play and CD_CUSTOMER and CUSTOMERNUMBER are distinct).

image.png


image.png

Best Answer

  • Sumanth V -Oracle
    Sumanth V -Oracle Rank 8 - Analytics & AI Strategist
    Answer ✓

    @Mirithu -

    The mismatch between your expected difference (538,342) and the result (581,037) suggests that the counts are being aggregated differently due to either:

    • A difference in the granularity of the calculations.
    • Overlapping or duplicate data due to join conditions or aggregation context.

    By verifying the aggregation context, inspecting joins, and validating the raw data, you should be able to pinpoint the issue and correct the calculation.

Answers

  • Federico Venturin - Oracle
    Federico Venturin - Oracle Mod

    Hi @Mirithu ,

    Can you please tell us something more about the dataset? Does it have multiple tables? How did you join them? Are the columns coming from different tables?

  • Philippe Lions-Oracle
    Philippe Lions-Oracle Mod

    Just a thought (may not be your question), you are already positive that functionally, you don't need count distincts in your calc, right ?

    Technically (COUNT(CD_CUSTOMER)) - (COUNT(CUSTOMERNUMBER)) will simply show a difference of how many rows have non null CD_Customer vs how many of these rows (assuming same star) have non null CUSTOMERNUMBER. Just checking.

  • Mirithu
    Mirithu Rank 3 - Community Apprentice

    Thank you @Sumanth V -Oracle

    The issue lies with the join used (though there are no duplicates).

    I removed all columns and left only the two but still got incorrect value. Then I changed to FULL OUTER join and the result is correct (LEFT, RIGHT and INNER were all giving different wrong results).
    I thought the calculations' resultant explicit values are what are used to compute the difference. I will have to understand how the joins are evaluated.

  • user7093388
    user7093388 Rank 2 - Community Beginner

    If you say the values ​​are different use count(distinct variable) in both cases and it should work.