Microsoft Outlook Add Mismatching Users

Summary:

I logged into the add-in with credentials that don't have access to the Add-in. I click OK and I am redirected to the add-in showing a 'connect' button. However, hitting that buttons tries to reconnect with the credentials I had entered before. What I would like is to log in with different credentials. That option seems to be missing somehow.

Am I missing something or is this actually the case?