Manager unable to edit Performance Document after submitting

Summary

In past for Standard Document we have been able to allow a manager to edit evaluation after submitting through our process flow settings but does not appear to be working in configuration below

Content

As stated above, for the past couple of years we have leveraged the functionality in process flows for the Manager to go back and edit a submitted evaluation for a standard document. This year we are trying to apply that same functionality to an Anytime Document and does not seem to be working. Please see our configuration for Anytime Document attached, we did not check the option "Do not allow additional edit of manager evaluation task when completed." Initially we thought maybe this was due to being an Anytime Document but tried recreating as a Standard Document and got same results.